A group of lawyers asked a Connecticut court on Watch Young & Beautiful Vol. 10 OnlineMonday to grant three traveling and working elephants "legal personhood," a status that would set these intelligent creatures free.
The lawyers, of the Nonhuman Rights Project organization, previously attempted to get courts in New York to recognize chimpanzees as persons, but couldn't sway the judges to accept that some intelligent animals should be given the same rights to free will as humans. Now, the Nonhuman Rights Project filed a petition of habeas corpus— a report of an unlawful imprisonment — for three elephants working at the traveling Commerford Zoo, based in Connecticut.
SEE ALSO: Jane Goodall still fights for endangered chimps. She needs your help.To these lawyers, elephants, like chimpanzees, should have a right to 'practical autonomy,' because they're self-aware, anticipate the future, and engage in sophisticated cultural practices like grieving. Accordingly, denying these creatures self-determination is disputing that they're scientifically proven to be cognitively sophisticated beings.
"We’re trying to force the legal system to accept science," Kevin Schneider, the Nonhuman Rights Project's executive director and attorney, told Mashable. "It’s like denying climate science or evolution. It’s denying that their autonomy matters as much to them as it does to us."
The lawyers said they picked Commerford Zoo because -- not only are the elephants there working and traveling -- but the zoo is based is Connecticut, a place they believe has favorable habeas corpuslaws.
Although there's no clear legal route to setting the Commerford Zoos' three elephants — Minnie, Beulah, and Karen — free, Schneider and his legal team have chosen to argue that elephants are advanced enough to be viewed as autonomous, free beings — like people.
"We have to make arguments that resonate within the legal system," said Schneider. "We can’t just say elephants are awesome.”
They might love them, but that’s not the point. They shouldn’t have the right to own them.
In response to the petition, the Commerford Zoo's owner, Tim Commerford, told The Washington Post, “They’re part of our family.” Additionally, the company's site states the animals "are well taken care of and we have strict rules about when and how they work."
Schneider isn't swayed by this defense.
"If you can imagine that you have a nice cousin that you say you treat well and keep chained up — if that’s how you treat family, that’s pretty bizarre," he said.
Even if the Commerford's truly care for their money-making elephants, which get rented for parties and other amusements, Schneider says the animals are still being denied their free will.
"They might love them, but that’s not the point. They shouldn’t have the right to own them," explained Schneider.
Schneider admits the legal battle ahead will be long. If his organization loses, they'll appeal. And if the Commerford's lose, they'll probably appeal too. But the Nonhuman Rights Projects appears ready to fight for the elephants' autonomy.
"It’s really about having a will," said Schneider. "And when you have a will you can suffer tremendously when you’re deprived of your will. These are intensely social beings — it’s really like having a prisoner in a solitary confinement in lots of these scenarios."
The end game is to get through an arduous legal battle and set the animals free to a sanctuary, at no cost to the Commerford Zoo (other than the loss of their animals, of course.) Specifically, the three elephants would be sent to a sanctuary run by the Performing Animal Welfare Society in San Andreas, Calif.
"It’s not the wild, what they should have, but it’s a hell of a lot better. They’re given space and autonomy," said Schneider.
Update Dec. 28 2017 at 5:00 p.m. EST: Ina statement, Nonhuman Rights Project president Steve Wise said that the Connecticut Superior Court dismissed the organization's petition for writ of habeas corpus on behalf of the three Commerford Zoo elephants. Wise plans to amend or refile the lawsuit. If this fails, he said he will appeal the court's decision.
NASA spacecraft snaps view of volcanoes erupting on distant world IoBest Apple AirTag deal: Apple AirTag 4NASA spacecraft saw something incredible near Jupiter's Great Red SpotThe C.U.P. Runneth OverNASA footage shows a moon landing like never beforeBest Apple AirTag deal: Apple AirTag 4Everything you need to know about Prime Day 2025Today's NYT mini crossword answers for June 20, 2025How Jenny Solares earned trust in her audience — and a few million followersRiver Plate vs. Urawa Red Diamonds 2025 livestream: Watch Club World Cup for freeHow to unblock Redtube for free in TexasNYT Strands hints, answers for June 25Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 7 might come in a bold new colorNYT Strands hints, answers for June 19When is Amazon Prime Day 2025? Official dates for the 4Today's NYT mini crossword answers for June 20, 2025Best power station deal: 47% off Bluetti Solar Generator Elite 200 V2Americans to witness a lunar eclipse blood moon. Here's who'll have good viewing weather.Best budget tablet deal: Get the Amazon Fire HD 8 Plus for $55England vs. Netherlands 2025 livestream: Watch U21 Euro 2025 for free How, why, and if the U.S. is banning TikTok Humane Society will give you a bad custom drawing of your pet for a $15 donation Etsy sellers are furious over new mandatory ad fees 'Quordle' today: See each 'Quordle' answer and hints for March 10 What is sensation play in BDSM? A handy guide. Netflix's 'I Think You Should Leave' set for May 30 season premiere Reflecting on the legacy of Hattie McDaniel, first Black actor to win an Oscar Looking to prevent coronavirus? Stop touching your face. Michael Jordan joked about his crying meme during speech about Kobe Why is it so tempting to rewatch your own Instagram Story? I don't know who needs to hear this, but the 'range' meme has the range What we can learn from books about deadly pandemics like 'The Stand' How to tell the difference between electric vehicles Coronavirus prevention has people making memes about how they can't stop touching their faces 'Ted Lasso' Season 3 review: Higher stakes, same old Ted The ending of 'You' Season 4 explained Congressman's viral tweet calls out House's double standard Escaped baboons go on the run, Twitter goes wild with primate jokes Wordle today: Here's the answer, hints for March 9 New Apple Music Classical app is launching this month
1.9903s , 10131.2890625 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Watch Young & Beautiful Vol. 10 Online】,Wisdom Convergence Information Network